Avraham Beer Sheva
There is a holiday called Halloween which is similar to Purim
where you dress up in a costume
If someone were to dress up as a Jew
Is it insulting?
No
Why is it not insulting?
I agree but I want to know...
Why? Because to dress like the son of the king is respect
Do you know what Halloween is?
Have you heard of it?
Jerusalem
No
It is a holiday for Christians actually not for Christians, but in America
where you wear a costume like here for Purim
I don't know it
It's like Purim
but not religious
If someone wore a costume of what you look like
or a Hassidic Jew
is it insulting?
I don't know what to tell you
Would you find it insulting?
Ask someone else
If someone were to dress up in the clothes you are wearing
meaning a costume
as a Jew
Is it insulting to you?
Shneor Kfar Chabad
No
Like in Purim, someone dresses up
as an Arab
or an Indian
what else
I am trying to think of examples
Do you see it as insulting?
No
You are Haredi (ultra-orthodox Jew)
Can I call you that?
I am a Jew
Double click to edit
Yehuda Jerusalem
Do you know what Halloween is?
Have you heard of it?
No
It is like Purim for non-Jews
they do it in Europe and the US
where they wear a costume
once a year
Let's say someone wore a costume like what you are wearing
wearing Haredi clothes
Is it insulting?
No
Someone not Jewish
No
Why not?
If it was something not nice
it would be insulting
But I say it is nice so it is not insulting at all
So you know what Halloween is
Yes
It's like Purim
If someone in America or Europe wore a costume that looked like you
as a religious Jew
What do you think of that?
Is it ok?
Insulting?
Insulting?
That people want to pretend to be dressed like me
I understand it
Who wouldn't want it?
No, not insulting at all
To be inulting
it depends on how someone looks at it
A person who feels there is something to be insulted by, will be insulted
by everything
A person who feels independent and good
on the contrary, will be happy about it
that someone wants to copy him
Even if he is doing it as a little joke
It is not really a joke laughing at Jews
It is like joking around like when people here wear costumes
of ancient Romans
or, I don't know
something else
For me it is really not insulting
because
a few reasons
I see it as
the same as...
I don't think... it's like, so what?
if someone wants to copy me
they can do it
again, what is there to be insulted by?
There isn't anything
One person dresses up like a cat and another like a famous Rabbi
they can invent an endless world
I see it exactly the opposite, the reality is that they have heard of me
We are such a small minority in the world
and yet everyone hears about us
There isn't anyone in the world who hasn't heard (about Jews)
Amazing
we are a handful of...
less than a million
and everyone knows who we are It's amazing
You are Hasids that is how you dress
Eliyahu and Baruch Netanya and Jerusalem
Do you know what Halloween is? Did you ever hear of it?
No - No
It is like Purim
You wear a costume of something
Like here, people dress up as ancient Greeks
or, I don't know
from another place, another country
You don't do that? - No
During Purim? - Oh, Purim
Do you do it?
What do you dress up as?
What do we dress up as usually?
Usually we wear a costume connected to Judaism like Mordechai
Let's say not connected to Judaism
So there are all kinds, tv personalities
Let's say it is ancient Greeks
or Romans
Romans, there isn't such a thing
We have never seen a costume like that ever
So what do people wear from different places?
Chinese?
Chinese, yes, I have seen - Japan?
Yes, there are Chinese and Japanese costumes
If someone in England or the USA dressed up like you two
would it be insulting to you?
No, it wouldn't be insulting to us
We are happy to share our culture
with the entire world, why not?
Even as a costume?
Even as a costume
It is like when people dress up as soldiers
or other things like that
These are positive things not negative
There are many actors in film that put on these clothes
of religious Jews
and after said that it has an effect on them
a lot of good thoughts towards religion
Even if they are not Jews?
No, if they are not Jews I don't know
I am talking about non-Jews
Maybe they want to convert? I don't know
Let's say they don't want to but
It also has an influence on their good thoughts towards the people of Israel
and our religion
They learn about the religion
what is the people of Israel
And even if not, it still
I support it I have no problem with it
Do you know what Halloween is?
Osher Jerusalem
You don't need to know what it is
It is an American holiday
where people put on costumes
like Purim
There is this holiday
If someone were to wear a costume
like here where people wear a costume of Native Americans
or ancient Romans
If someone wore a costume of how you are dressed
as a Hasid
is it ok?
No
Why not?
Does it insult you?
Yes
Why?
Because
What "because"?
Give a reason
It insults me if a person wants to be a Hasid
but is not a Hasid
If he wants to be a Hasid he should be a Hasid
He can study Torah Every Jew can study Torah
Every Jew who wants to study Torah
But for people who are not Jewish
who do that
Then they shouldn't dress like a Hasid For what?
There aren't other costumes, my brother?
What costumes do you wear for Purim?
I don't wear costumes
I put on a hat, that is it
But there are people who wear costumes, no?
I don't know
What do you mean you don't know?
What? I don't understand
For Purim, people dress up as something
No?
As something?
As an ancient Greek
You are right
Why not?
Why is one insulting and the other isn't?
That is the question
It is not insulting
Say what you want
I am just...
It doesn't insult me Everyone can dress just like me
But I don't understand
what is the insult
why be insulted
why a person would be insulted
because someone dressed like him?
I wasn't trying to convince you
I am asking
I am also asking
I don't have a.... My opinion
If I saw someone not Jewish
let's say in American or Canada
in a costume as a Jew
I would think "what is that?"
I would think it is strange
but then I would think "I dress up as something else"
So why not? - True, why not
So I wish all those who want to wear a costume
dress up only as Hasids
put on the hats
they can also get Shtreimel, no?
True
Like the Ashkenazis, wear the Shtreimel
the hat, the suit
I can arrange for Tfilin
You are killing me
On me. Really, I mean it
Really
It is not that I forced you...
It is not like I told you that you have to say that
No, you didn't
It wasn't forced
If it was...
Why not?
The entire Nation of Israel
We are blessed to be the Nation of Israel
Jerusalem is the holy city
We will build Jerusalem
If someone were to wear a costume
like him (her husband)
Eden and Ephraim Beer Sheva
like Purim there is Halloween
Would it bother you? Is it something hurtful?
or insulting?
Of course
How?
Because it is not real
They are making
a joke
In my opinion
You don't agree?
So what is your answer? Say it
I understand where you are coming from
The cultural appropriation issue
going on now in the USA and Canada
So the truth
if you are not making fun of someone
it wouldn't bother me
What I would be concerned about
if someone were to dress up
in order to make a terror attack
I wouldn't mind that at all
I understand what the problem is going on in the US
and I really don't agree with it
(watch as I get myself in trouble)
Well, I disagree with that
God created us We didn't create God
but whatever, you have your opinion
God has his
and we share His
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét